Search | Site Map | Newsletter | RSS | About CD | Contact Us | Advertise
Canada's Online Auto Magazine

Peter

Home
Classifieds
Contests
Auto News
New Vehicles
Previews
First Drives
Test Drives
Day-by-Day
Inside Story
Luxury Cars
Trucks
RVs
Buyer's Guide
Price Guide
Photos
Features
Winter Driving
Green Scene
50-Litre Challenge
More features
Advice
Steering You Right
Product Reviews
Book Reviews
Calculators
Crossword
Used Car Reviews
Auto Shows
Toronto 2010
Chicago 2010
Montreal 2010
Detroit 2010
LA 2009
New York 2009
Vancouver 2009
Auto Tech
Classics
Forums
Web Directory
Search CanadianDriver
Browse the Archive
www.canadiandriver.com


September 29, 2009
Share |
Subscribe to RSS Feed

Test Drive: 2009 Brabus Smart Fortwo cabriolet

2009 Brabus Smart Fortwo cabriolet
2009 Brabus Smart Fortwo cabriolet. Click image to enlarge

Manufacturer’s web site
smart Canada

Join CanadianDriver’s Facebook group
Follow CanadianDriver on Twitter

Review and photos by Peter Bleakney

Find this vehicle in CanadianDriver’s Classified Ads

Photo Gallery:
2009 Brabus smart fortwo cabriolet

Toronto, Ontario – How can something so cute have me so conflicted?

Spock, in his Vulcan wisdom, would surely declare the 2009 Smart Fortwo as completely illogical. Why? Designed for congested European inner- cities, it’s a fish out of water here; it requires Premium gasoline; its halting five-speed sequential transmission seriously tries the patience of even the most saintly. Mother Theresa would put her fist through the fabric top in no time. Its 70-hp 999-cc naturally aspirated three-cylinder engine is pretty gutless yet fails to return the claimed 5.4 L/100 km combined (I saw 6.3). And it rides like a rickshaw.

Tell Spock this Brabus Smart Cabriolet nudges 30 grand with taxes and freight and he might even laugh – which would be a first for a Vulcan.

2009 Brabus Smart Fortwo cabriolet
2009 Brabus Smart Fortwo cabriolet. Click image to enlarge

And yet, seeing this cheery silver micro-car all squat and butchy on its Brabus alloys brought a smile to my face every morning. All I wanted to do was hop in, roll back that big soft-top and putter around town, happily doing a bobble-head doll impersonation as the tranny worked its devilish trickery.

How can that be?

Well, that’s the magic of the Smart, I guess. Like a puppy, it’s cute, lovable and infuriating. Contributing to my renewed affliction…er, affection this time ‘round was the Brabus package (available in both coupe and cabrio) that adds an extra hit of style, greatly improved handling and $3,650 to the bottom line. You can get a Brabus Smart in any colour you like as long as it’s black or silver.

Brabus is a German tuning firm best known for imbuing Mercedes products with obscene amounts of power. In this case, the Smart’s rear-mounted drivetrain is untouched, but Brabus has massaged the suspension bits, lowered the ride height by 10 mm and added some stylish “Monoblock VII” alloys – 15s in the front and 17s out back. Wide 215/35R17 tires fill the rear haunches, and sporty side skirts and revised front and rear facias add some flair. A Brabus tuned exhaust gives this puppy some snarl.

2009 Brabus Smart Fortwo cabriolet
2009 Brabus Smart Fortwo cabriolet. Click image to enlarge

Up until now, you could never put “Smart” and “handling” in the same sentence without including such descriptives as “extreme understeer” or “yikes”. This Brabus Fortwo is actually fun to toss into the corners – there’s even a hint of oversteer to be found. The steering has surprising heft for a car this tiny. Electronic safety nets include ABS with electronic brake force distribution and brake assist, and electronic stability control with hill start assist.

Without having a regular smart to compare it to, I can’t say if the ride is any worse in the Brabus. That said, you sure know where the bumps are.

The betrothed and I took it to a yoga class, and after bucking over the first road blemish, she involuntarily blurted “Oh gawd!”, then launched into a flurry of, er, smarting vitriol that surely knocked her down a few rungs on the karmic ladder.

2009 Brabus Smart Fortwo cabriolet
2009 Brabus Smart Fortwo cabriolet
2009 Brabus Smart Fortwo cabriolet. Click image to enlarge

The Brabus interior gets heated leather seats, a leather shift knob, three-spoke leather wheel with paddle shifters, Brabus metallic sport pedals, velour floor mats, auto climate control, special trim and five-speaker six-disc audio.

As with all Smarts, the driving position is excellent featuring plenty of headroom, legroom, and a high seating position that offers a panoramic view. Once behind the wheel, you easily forget how small this car really is. The best way to drive a Smart smoothly is by using the paddle shifters and lifting the throttle slightly during upshifts. If you try to hurry, it seems to fight back, becoming even more hesitant.

The powered fabric top is a stroke of brilliance, and in my opinion, a necessary piece of Smart kit. Using a button on the console, it rolls back in two stages – at any speed. A button on the key fob allows remote operation. The upper door rails can be removed too, and they store in recesses in the trunk lid.

It seems the first thing people ask is, “Do you feel safe driving that?”, and my answer is “Sorta.” I’ve seen the European and IIHS (Insurance Institute for Highway Safety) crash test results that suggest the rigid Tridion safety-cell and sandwich-floor construction (wherein the drivetrain slides under the occupants in a rear end collision) indeed work as advertised. But there are certain basic laws of physics that can’t be ignored.

2009 Brabus Smart Fortwo cabriolet
2009 Brabus Smart Fortwo cabriolet. Click image to enlarge

In light of the Smart Fortwo’s need for Premium fuel and its less than jaw-dropping economy, the smartest Smart you can get is the $14,990 Pure Coupe. But even that’s a logical leap of faith when you consider a number of cars – Toyota Yaris and Honda Fit, for starters – will likely have lower running costs and be immeasurably more functional and pleasant to drive.

But is anyone who’s seriously considering a Smart really cross-shopping “normal” cars? I believe successful Smart Fortwo ownership requires giving up all preconceptions of what a car should be, because it’s not a real car. You drive a Smart on its own terms. Yes, it’s slow and jerky, it gets blown around on the highway and won’t carry much of anything, but it’s also a clever and intriguing design exercise that flips the bird at automotive convention – a high-style rolling trinket giving grins and grimaces in equal measure.

It’s enough to give Spock a Vulcan meltdown.

Pricing: 2009 Brabus Smart Fortwo cabriolet
  • Base price: $24,900
  • Options: $785 (silver metallic paint $430; alarm system $210, front fog lights $145)
  • A/C tax: $100
  • Freight: $1,295
  • Price as tested: $27,080
    Click here for options, dealer invoice prices and factory incentives

    Specifications
  • Specifications: 2009 smart fortwo

    Related articles on CanadianDriver
  • Smart Fortwo 10th Anniversary Edition limited to 10
  • Smart introduces 2009 Fortwo BRABUS at LA Auto Show
  • http://www.canadiandriver.com/2008/11/02/20000th-smart-fortwo-delivered-in-the-us.htm
  • Smart unveils Fortwo with electric drive
  • Smart fortwo celebrates 10-year anniversary
  • Test Drive: 2008 Smart Fortwo Passion Coupe
  • Test Drive: 2008 Smart Fortwo Cabriolet Passion
  • Smart delivers 100,000th redesigned Fortwo
  • Smart unveils hybrid Fortwo at Geneva auto show
  • Inside Story: 2008 Smart Fortwo cabriolet
  • First Drive: 2008 Smart Fortwo
  • Used Vehicle Review: Smart Fortwo, 2005-2006
  • Feature: Smart Fortwo Road Trip
  • Test Drive: 2006 Smart Fortwo Winter Test
  • Across Canada in a Smart Fortwo
  • Test Drive: 2005 Smart Fortwo Cabriolet
  • Auto Tech: Smart fortwo crash-test results
  • First Drive: 2005 smart fortwo cabriolet
  • First Drive: 2005 Smart Fortwo

    Competitors
  • None

    Crash test results
  • National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA)
  • Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (IIHS)
  • View full article on one page
    Share |
    Subscribe to RSS Feed

    More Green Reviews...
    More Green Scene...
    More Luxury Cars...
    More Smart...
    More Test Drives...

    Share |
    Subscribe to RSS Feed

    Click here to enterEnter for an opportunity to win two tickets to the Carroll Shelby Gala Reception, to be held February 10, 7:00 - 10:00 p.m. at the Metro Toronto Convention Centre. A value of $300! Enter today and every day until Sunday, February 7, 2010.

    Green Scene                     
    Green Car Reviews
    Green Car Buyer's Guide
    Eco News
    Fuel Economy Challenge
    Hybrids
    Green Features
    Green Future
    Technology

    Untitled
    Quick Links
    Research: Buyer's Guide, Price Guide, First Drives, Test Drives, Luxury Cars, Trucks, Used Vehicles
    Photos: Galleries - Ten thousand BIG photos
    Newsletter: Subscribe | RSS: Daily updates
    Untitled
    © 1999-2010, CanadianDriver Communications Inc., all rights reserved
    Disclaimer | Privacy | Advertise