Home
CarTalk Blogs
General
Sedans
Coupes
Sports Cars
Trucks/SUVs
Forums
The Parking Lot
The Gravel Trail
The Showroom
The Garage
The Press Room
User Agreement
Contact Us
Do you mod your car?
Extensively
Midly
No thanks
I want to....


Total votes: 32
View results

Blog Search
Archives

Don't miss these great features

Photo Galleries
1000s of photos, with full screen enlargements, all 2006 and 2007 models



More Day-by-Day Reviews


November 6th, 2007 by James Bergeron

Picture Gallery: 2008 Honda Civic Si Sedan     | Day 1 | Day 2 | Day 3 | Day 4

Day 1:

2008 Honda Civic Si Sedan
Click Image to Enlarge
After a short hiatus of sorts I am back with another car. This time, something a little sporty in nature yet still reasonable on the pocket book: the much debated and perhaps anticipated 2008 Honda Civic Si Sedan. Originally, rumours had this car as only being available in the U.S., but Honda has decided to bring it to Canada.

Sporting a very modern and high tech look, the new Civic has been a love-it or hate-it design for many over the past couple of years. It seems to be growing on many and certainly sales are not floundering as some had assumed would happen when Honda decided to use a two-tiered digital dash rather than the traditional analog style.

2008 Honda Civic Si Sedan
Click Image to Enlarge

The Civic Si sedan in the Canadian market is a little bit of a question mark, with the Acura brand getting the CSX (only available in Canada) as the more luxurious and sporting Civic, so it seems like bringing an Si sedan to Canada could only cause Honda to compete with themselves.

So what does the Si bring to the table? Quite a lot actually — minus the leather, navigation system and a few other goodies available on the CSX Type-S as well as the $5,000 price premium.


The Honda Civic Si is powered by a high revving 2.0litre four cylinder engine which produces 197hp at 7800 rpm and a redline of 8000rpm. This model is only available with one transmission and that is a short throw close ratio 6-speed manual transmission — truly a performance oriented machine.

The Si comes standard with a good list of features as well, including: a seven-speaker premium audio system including sub-woofer, cruise control with steering wheel mounted controls, air-conditioning, tilt and telescoping steering wheel, sunroof and 17-inch aluminum alloy wheels.

2008 Honda Civic Si Sedan
MSRP as tested inc. destination & delivery: $27,975

For more information on Honda and the Civic visit Honda Canada

Day 2:

2008 Honda Civic Si Sedan
Click Image to Enlarge
I have a few things to say about the interior and exterior styling of this car, some good and some bad, but I believe after a day or so of driving the Civic Si, I have made up my mind on my relationship with the styling. I’ll start with the outside: the fiji blue pearl colour is rather striking but the overall design doesn’t really do it for me.

But looks are subjective, so let’s move on. Even though the interior is pretty much a love it or hate it design I’m in both camps. I actually love the two-tiered dash. The digital speedometer is way up by the windshield which allows you to keep your eyes on the road while also being able to watch your speed and fuel gauge.

2008 Honda Civic Si Sedan
Click Image to Enlarge
I do wonder why Honda didn’t go with a conventional design with a heads-up display for a similar effect; I believe it would be just as effective, although perhaps it would be more costly. There are a lot of good things to say about the interior: the seats are great and very supportive on the Si and the sliding arm-rest in the console allows you to get very comfortable, making the Si a joy to drive.

The audio and HVAC controls are easy to reach, and the steering wheel controls are placed perfectly. Cubby holes are plentiful in the interior leaving room for two coffees, your cellphone and many more knick-knacks.

I do have a few qualms with the interior, too, though. I really dislike the plastic sun-visors, for two reasons: one for being hard plastic and two, for extending so long I have to lean far back in order not to get hit in the head by them as I swing them out to the side window.

I also find the interior a little cramped, mainly for headroom. I believe this may be because of the sunroof; it certainly encroaches on the already low roof line. Getting in and out in tighter parking spaces had me hitting my head on entry a few times.

Day 3:

2008 Honda Civic Si Sedan
Click Image to Enlarge
I know everyone is heavily anticipating my driving comments on the Civic Si. There certainly is a lot of debate about torque VS horsepower in the forums, and whether the Civic Si is a pain to drive in the city due to its high-revving nature. What one must remember is the Si has plenty more horsepower and torque than your average economy car, which would generally be strapped with an automatic transmission; so in short, of course the Si has no problem at city speeds.

In fact, tooling around town the Civic Si need never be revved about 2,500rpm, or 3,000rpm if you want to be really aggressive. It easily keeps up with traffic and passes without much hesitation. I have been able to keep the Si in fifth gear at 50km/h with no problems and after 65km/h sixth gear can be used for cruising without feeling the need to shift for more acceleration.

2008 Honda Civic Si Sedan
Click Image to Enlarge
Of course the fun doesn’t really start unless you do shift, for a couple of reasons. One, it gets your blood boiling as the engine hits its high notes; and two, the short throw shifter feels wonderful to row along all day. If anything the Si can be a little too fast. If you really want to hear it scream and get into the second cam change over 6,000rpm, you will be exceeding the speed limit in very short order.

Although the shifter is a joy to use, I find getting into third gear to be a bit on the dodgy side; it seems more notched than the other gears. What do I say about the handling? Well, the Civic Si exhibits a very well-sorted chassis that feels like the rear end is about to step out on corner exit which feels quite nice, actually. That is, until I step on the accelerater to prod it a little and everything sorts itself out, reminding me that this is a front wheel drive vehicle.

The suspension is firm, which I don’t mind, but it tends to make for a bumpy ride in the Si rather just a firm one. The cabin is ultra quiet at speeds below 100km/h but at 120km/h wind noise does start to become noticeable; this is in no way out of the ordinary for this class of vehicle, though. Also to note is the 3,000 cruising revolutions (rpms) at 120km/h on the highway in sixth gear.

And, of course, what review of the Civic Si would be complete without a mention of the hanging revs. I am referring to the fact that when up shifting to the next gear and releasing the gas pedal the Civic holds its rpms at the point where the pedal was released. I find this only causes jarring shifts when quickly accelerating at lower rpms. I noticed at higher rpms everything seems to click and when driving slowly in the city it isn’t an issue either. The jarring can be eliminated by some slick clutch work as well but I’m not sure why I would want to have to slip the clutch just to avoid a slight rocking motion.

Day 4:

2008 Honda Civic Si Sedan
Click Image to Enlarge
I found a few “easter eggs” in the Civic Si over the weekend. I hadn’t folded the seats down before I had to pick up a piece of lumber. To my surprise, two pull strings in the trunk release the back seats of the Civic, which saves climbing into the back seats to put them down — I was impressed.

I never really got use to the sun-visors. Sounds like a small thing, but driving towards the sun everyday after work I constantly had a hard time lowering them, because you can only grab them in one place, and swinging them sideways requires ducking or tilting my head.

Gas mileage was fairly good during the week, but having recently moved, my commute is much more highway-type driving than city driving, making it tough to gauge if the Civic really did that well. I averaged 8.6L/100km which is a fairly good number if my mix of city and highway hadn’t changed, but at 80% or so highway driving, perhaps it is a little high for a Civic. One does have to remember though this is not your typical Civic; 197hp doesn’t come for free and premium fuel is also recommended.

Overall I found the Civic Si easy to drive: comfortable and quick, and certainly a fun drive on the twisty roads that are part of my new commute and acceleration is fairly brisk. Seating 4 comfortably was no problem during my monthly lunch with the boys and everyone seemed impressed by the Civic’s power comfort and spaciousness.

*Rating out of 5:

2008 Honda Civic Si Sedan
Acceleration 4"
Handling 4
Comfort 3half
Interior 3half
Audio System 4
Gas Mileage 4

*Rating based on vehicle’s classification

2008 Honda Civic Si Sedan
MSRP as tested inc. destination & delivery: $27,975<

91 Responses to “Day-by-Day Review: 2008 Honda Civic Si Sedan”


NOTE: This page displays the most recent 25 responses only.
to view the remaining posts please follow through to the forum thread.
  1. SIVIC Says:
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eToFmoi6xOY

    btw:
    @ 50kph:
    1st gear = 6850RPM
    2nd gear = 4400RPM
    3rd gear = 3300RPM
    4th gear = 2400RPM
    5th gear = 1900RPM
    6th gear = 1400RPM  (2000RPM at 72kph)
  2. Demosthenes X Says:
    Yes!....that’s great in a lab but I drive in the real world.

    Because these cars don't have multiple gears one can switch into to pass or go uphill...  Hell, most Hybrids have CVTs, so you don't even need to change gears.  You just need to press the go button and the car does all the work.
  3. mdxtasy Says:
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eToFmoi6xOY

    btw:
    @ 50kph:
    1st gear = 6850RPM
    2nd gear = 4400RPM
    3rd gear = 3300RPM
    4th gear = 2400RPM
    5th gear = 1900RPM
    6th gear = 1400RPM  (2000RPM at 72kph)

    Geez that's awfully low in 6th.  I'm at 3k in 2nd gear when at 50kph.  I like it there.  Because right beside that is where the meat of the power is.
  4. wing Says:
    I find that's a little low I haven't been putting it into 6th until about 70kph
  5. SIVIC Says:
    maybe it's just because I live in a slow city..

    I do, however, get 500kms/tank. (about 8 L/100km)
  6. Snowman Says:
    Adding a half second reaction time to a panic situation for the sake of a few drops of fuel is unsafe.
  7. Arctic_White Says:
    The chassis is, by all accounts, fantastic.  And the car is so shockingly ugly inside and out that you might be distracted from the total lack of torque.

    #s can be misleading.  Have you driven one?  Wink

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=r0XuDIXx_5A
  8. Arctic_White Says:
    Many never understand, it has nothing to do with high revving even.  Torque is ONLY a NUMBER.  Everyone constantly forgets to factor in gear ratio, final drive and weight.


    Precisely.

    As a future Si/Type S owner, and a current Mazda3 owner, I'd like to ask you how the Si compares to your Mazda3 Sport in everyday driving. 
  9. Arctic_White Says:
    Even for sporty cars, efficiency is important to me.  However, I don't really care about how much I pay at the pump.

    Is the engine operating at top efficiency when it's being lugged around at 50kph while in 6th gear?

    Who ever said the engine is being lugged?

    If you were to floor it at this engine speed - of course yes.  But just having a 1 mm push on the gas pedal (DBW civics have a wide on/off gap on the throttle) surely does not.

    I'd much rather hold a speed at 2000RPM, barely touching the throttle and keeping the engine calm, than holding 3000RPM and holding my right foot further probed in.

    I'm with Sivic.  One thing I really like about Si is it's dual personality: keep the revs low and enjoy awesome fuel economy; want to have some fun then rev it past 5,800 rpm and enjoy.   Kiss

  10. airbalancer Says:
    Many never understand, it has nothing to do with high revving even.  Torque is ONLY a NUMBER.  Everyone constantly forgets to factor in gear ratio, final drive and weight.


    Precisely.

    As a future Si/Type S owner, and a current Mazda3 owner, I'd like to ask you how the Si compares to your Mazda3 Sport in everyday driving. 

    How Wing know, has he driven is Mazda 3 more then 5000km since he got it
  11. wing Says:
    Hey I have over 8000km now -- and drove it 600+ last week.

    In comparison the regular Mazda3 has a nicer interior than the Civic IMO, although the civic has more cubby holes and such if you require that.  The Mazda is also more comfortable and quiet than the civic on the road as the civic (even in 6th gear) revs rather high and sounds buzzy.

    But the Civic is faster so that does offset it.  In term for daily driving they are fairly equal for power output and driveability / fun factor.
  12. r3cc0s Says:
    IMO the new Sentra Spec-V is worth looking at as well
    apparently slightly faster 1/4 and 0-60 and slightly better on gas
    likely due to more torque from a 2.5

    I think it looks badder assed too
  13. Mitlov Says:
    IMO the new Sentra Spec-V is worth looking at as well
    apparently slightly faster 1/4 and 0-60 and slightly better on gas
    likely due to more torque from a 2.5

    I think it looks badder assed too

    Read this comparison review involving the Spec V before you buy.

    http://www.caranddriver.com/comparisons/12635/2007-volkswagen-gti-vs-2007-subaru-impreza-wrx-tr-vs-2007-mini-cooper-s-vs-2007-nissan-sentra-se-r-spec-v-vs-2007-mazdaspeed-3-grand-touring.html
  14. Zombie Says:
    IMO the new Sentra Spec-V is worth looking at as well
    apparently slightly faster 1/4 and 0-60 and slightly better on gas
    likely due to more torque from a 2.5

    I think it looks badder assed too

    I don't know about Badder but the assed part for sure!
  15. Arctic_White Says:
    Hey I have over 8000km now -- and drove it 600+ last week.

    In comparison the regular Mazda3 has a nicer interior than the Civic IMO, although the civic has more cubby holes and such if you require that.  The Mazda is also more comfortable and quiet than the civic on the road as the civic (even in 6th gear) revs rather high and sounds buzzy.

    But the Civic is faster so that does offset it.  In term for daily driving they are fairly equal for power output and driveability / fun factor.

    I'm surprised that you didn't mention anything about LSD.  Limited-slip differential really helps with handling, and enhances the car's appeal. 

  16. SIVIC Says:
    Hey I have over 8000km now -- and drove it 600+ last week.

    In comparison the regular Mazda3 has a nicer interior than the Civic IMO, although the civic has more cubby holes and such if you require that.  The Mazda is also more comfortable and quiet than the civic on the road as the civic (even in 6th gear) revs rather high and sounds buzzy.

    But the Civic is faster so that does offset it.  In term for daily driving they are fairly equal for power output and driveability / fun factor.

    I'm surprised that you didn't mention anything about LSD.  Limited-slip differential really helps with handling, and enhances the car's appeal. 



    Hey Arctic, what's your gas consumption?   

    I'm getting about 8L/100KM city.
  17. Arctic_White Says:

    Hey Arctic, what's your gas consumption?   

    I'm getting about 8L/100KM city.



    8L per 100 is good!  What's your secret?

    I'm averaging about 9.8 L/100 kms, but that's pure city.

    As you're well aware, in Vancouver, one can't just drive at 55 km/h and cruise in 5th gear.  Traffic prohibits me from driving at a steady speed (engine or actual) thus my fuel consumption isn't as good as it could be.

    For comparison, I averaged about 9.3 L/100 kms in my Mazda3 on the same conditions.  (All-time average for my previous car was 7.9L/100 kms but that included quite a bit of highway driving.)


    PS: VTEC is addicting, eh?  I love driving the Si even if I have no reason to!  Couldn't say that about Mazda3...
  18. SIVIC Says:

    Hey Arctic, what's your gas consumption?   

    I'm getting about 8L/100KM city.



    8L per 100 is good!  What's your secret?

    I'm averaging about 9.8 L/100 kms, but that's pure city.

    As you're well aware, in Vancouver, one can't just drive at 55 km/h and cruise in 5th gear.  Traffic prohibits me from driving at a steady speed (engine or actual) thus my fuel consumption isn't as good as it could be.

    For comparison, I averaged about 9.3 L/100 kms in my Mazda3 on the same conditions.  (All-time average for my previous car was 7.9L/100 kms but that included quite a bit of highway driving.)


    PS: VTEC is addicting, eh?  I love driving the Si even if I have no reason to!  Couldn't say that about Mazda3...

    haha, honestly, I have not touched vtec for weeks.   It's way more power than I need in first gear, and it's illegal speeds in second.

    Have you had 3rd gear not go in properly yet?
  19. Arctic_White Says:
    Yeah, I've noticed that sometimes there are issues with the 3rd gear.

    I'm thinking of doing a MTF change with Amsoil, as per your recommendation.  Do you know the cost for it?

    As it is, i dislike going to the dealership...   I may go get it done at MIDAS or something.  Do you have any recommendationas to where to get it done?
  20. B2 Says:
    Quote
    PS: VTEC is addicting, eh?  I love driving the Si even if I have no reason to!  Couldn't say that about Mazda3...

    We could meet up, you could drive my Mazdaspeed3.  That would change your mind...
  21. SIVIC Says:
    Yeah, I've noticed that sometimes there are issues with the 3rd gear.

    I'm thinking of doing a MTF change with Amsoil, as per your recommendation.  Do you know the cost for it?

    As it is, i dislike going to the dealership...   I may go get it done at MIDAS or something.  Do you have any recommendationas to where to get it done?

    I'm not even sure Midas will carry it.. but just call around (maybe try the specialty car shops).  I think I just needed two bottles, and I think the bill was less than $40.

    https://www.amsoil.com/storefront/mtf.aspx
  22. Arctic_White Says:
    Quote
    PS: VTEC is addicting, eh?  I love driving the Si even if I have no reason to!  Couldn't say that about Mazda3...

    We could meet up, you could drive my Mazdaspeed3.  That would change your mind...

    Let's do it!  You live in Squamish, eh?  Going up there to meet you will in itself be a good drive.  I'll PM you. 
  23. Arctic_White Says:
    Yeah, I've noticed that sometimes there are issues with the 3rd gear.

    I'm thinking of doing a MTF change with Amsoil, as per your recommendation.  Do you know the cost for it?

    As it is, i dislike going to the dealership...   I may go get it done at MIDAS or something.  Do you have any recommendationas to where to get it done?

    I'm not even sure Midas will carry it.. but just call around (maybe try the specialty car shops).  I think I just needed two bottles, and I think the bill was less than $40.

    https://www.amsoil.com/storefront/mtf.aspx

    Thanks for the link!  I'll ask around and worse comes to worst, will just go the dealer and get it done at the same time as when I do the oil change. 
  24. Leviathan Says:
    Let's do it!  You live in Squamish, eh?  Going up there to meet you will in itself be a good drive.  I'll PM you. 
    There is a hell of a lot of road construction going on so don't expect much  Smiley
  25. Arctic_White Says:
    Let's do it!  You live in Squamish, eh?  Going up there to meet you will in itself be a good drive.  I'll PM you. 
    There is a hell of a lot of road construction going on so don't expect much  Smiley

    Oh...  but what if one were to go early in the morning?  Like 7:30 am?


NOTE: This page displays the most recent 25 responses only.
to view the remaining posts please follow through to the forum thread.

Comments are closed.

© 2005 - 2008 CarTalkCanada & 1999 - 2008 CanadianDriver Communications Inc, all rights reserved.

You are visitor # to our site.

Click here to advertise
CarTalkCanada is a member
of the AOL Canada Media Network.
hit tracker