Home
CarTalk Blogs
General
Sedans
Coupes
Sports Cars
Trucks/SUVs
Forums
The Parking Lot
The Gravel Trail
The Showroom
The Garage
The Press Room
User Agreement
Contact Us
Should Drivers get re-tested for licensing?
Every 5 years
Every 10 years
After a certain age
Never


Total votes: 1657
View results

Blog Search
Archives

Don't miss these great features

Photo Galleries
1000s of photos, with full screen enlargements, all 2006 - 2009 models



More Day-by-Day Reviews


May 12th, 2009 by James Bergeron

Picture Gallery: 2009 Nissan Maxima 3.5 SV     | Day 1 | Day 2 | Day 3 | Day 4 | Discuss

Day 1:

2009 Nissan Maxima SV
Click Image to Enlarge
From the small and economical to the large and luxurious, that is the way it goes sometimes; an advantage for the luxurious part, perhaps but a disadvantage on the size front. Generally, I have no use for a large car so they do not swoon me as they would some, but I will admit I like the ride and feel you generally get in a longer-wheelbase car.

This week I am piloting the 2009 Nissan Maxima — yet another redesigned version of this car, as Nissan had felt it had lost its edge. “In recent years, competitive vehicles have caught up with Maxima in ‘sporty’ looks and performance,” said Ian Forsyth, Director, Product and Corporate Planning, Nissan Canada Inc.

2009 Nissan Maxima SV
Click Image to Enlarge
According to Nissan, the 2009 Maxima is inspired by the concurrent top-secret development of the 2009 Nissan GT-R supercar. In designing this car, Nissan threw away positioning words like “conservative” and “balanced” and concentrated instead on new concepts and qualities like “addictive performance,” “striking,” “commanding” and “powerful.”

My first impressions? Well, it does sort of remind you of the GT-R when you step back and take it in. It must have impressed the teenagers at the mall as well, as a group of them were gawking at it. Either that, or they had visions of the old Maxima commercials where their lives flashed before their eyes when they placed their hand on the fender.

The 2009 Maxima’s 3.5-litre DOHC 24-valve V6 is now rated at 290 horsepower and 261 lb-ft of torque, increases of 35 horsepower and 9 lb-ft of torque over the 2008 Maxima.

Gone are the model designations of the past. The Maxima is available in only one model designation — the 3.5 SV. Starting at $38,700, available packages include: the Sport package for a total of $40,750, the Sport and Tech package bumps the price to $43,200, while the premium package (as my tester is equipped) goes for $41,850, and, of course, there’s the Premium package with navigation for an additional $2,100.

2009 Nissan Maxima 3.5 SV
MSRP as tested (including destination): $43,410

For more information on Nissan and the Maxima visit Nissan Canada

Day 2:

2009 Nissan Maxima SVClick Image to Enlarge
I am somewhat surprised by the reader comments this week. The Maxima tends to have a loyal following, but many seem to have trouble understanding its place in Nissan’s lineup alongside the similarly sized Altima and Infiniti G37. I agree to a point, but you can never have too many choices as a consumer and the Maxima is a different car in many respects than the Altima.

The first thing I noticed when I sat in the 2009 Maxima was the steering wheel, which seemed small. It turns out it is smaller than a typical steering wheel in a sedan, and smaller than the previous generation Maxima’s steering wheel.

2009 Nissan Maxima SV
Click Image to Enlarge
Not only is the steering wheel smaller, but the Nissan Maxima has the quickest steering ratio of any Nissan sedan (15.2:1) to help provide a more sporty feel on the road — and it works!

The second thing I noticed was the huge sunroof, a dual-panel example that nearly spans the entire roof of the car. This is part of the Premium package. The next item to jump out at me was the cooled seats; as I started to drive away, the cool air from below ensured that I wasn’t sweating in the black leather seats. This is also part of the Premium package.

In base form, the Maxima is fairly loaded up, including: 18-inch alloy wheels, a power glass moonroof, leather seats, heated steering wheel, keyless entry and intelligent key push button start, Bluetooth hands free, auto on/off headlights and a Bose nine-speaker stereo system; the standard features list is quite long.

The Premium package added to my tester just builds on that and for $3,150 it is not a bad deal. Other than what I previously mentioned you get: an iPod connection, rear view camera with 7-inch screen, power tilt / telescopic steering, premium leather seating, mood lighting, rear seat armrest with HVAC controls, auto-dimming driver’s side mirror and more.

The Maxima really seems to be about maximum features and even though purists may rather have a rear-wheel drive layout, the front wheel drive setup of the Maxima allows for better packaging, more interior space and a lower production cost.

Day 3:

2009 Nissan Maxima SV
Click Image to Enlarge
The 2009 Nissan Maxima may be a large vehicle but it does not feel like it on the road. I wouldn’t go as far as saying it handles as well as the GT-R which it was designed in step with, but is a great performer for this category of vehicle. Believe it or not, the Maxima was tuned on “The Ring” racetrack in Germany, like many of the high end sports cars and sports sedans of today.

“A number of product changes came directly from the NĂŒrburgring trials, including enhancements to the braking and transmission systems,” said Forsyth. “But more importantly, it gave notice to the entire Nissan organization that the new Maxima is back solidly in the performance arena where it rightfully belongs.”

2009 Nissan Maxima SV
Click Image to Enlarge
Although I’ve never driven the NĂŒrburgring Nordschleife myself (besides in video games), they say it is a very demanding circuit as it has every type of corner, as well as a bumpy surface, which could be a disaster at high speeds with a badly-tuned suspension. But I would venture to guess the average Maxima buyer isn’t heading out to the track so this is all irrelevant. What is relevant, though, is that it drives well.

The 3.5-litre V6 that Nissan uses in some form or another in nearly their entire lineup puts out 290 horsepower and 261lb-ft of torque in this iteration. The transmission is a CVT (continuously variable transmission), but the Maxima has what I would consider the best CVT on the market right now: it is unbelievably smooth and the VQ-series V6 engine works perfectly with it.

The Maxima’s chassis and suspension feel tight and solid. Over railway tracks, nearly no vibrations are transferred back to the driver except where you would expect - through the steering. The smaller diameter steering wheel begs you to toss the Maxima into a corner and see what it can do. The car is quite capable, and so is the VDC (Vehicle Dynamic Control) system, as I found out when I tossed it in a corner perhaps a little too quickly.

Day 4:

2009 Nissan Maxima SV
Click Image to Enlarge
All week I was staring at one particular gauge on the Maxima — the fuel gauge. It wasn’t moving! I know the fuel tank is large, and I know the CVT transmission helps get better mileage but we are still talking about a 290hp V6 engine, so the laws of consumption still need to apply in some form.

The CVT does do a really good job of keeping the revs down; at 80km/h, the Maxima is barely idling, while at 100km/h it is still under 2,000 rpm. The result is phenomenal gas mileage for a vehicle of this size and power. Over the week I averaged 10L/100km, though for most of the week I was hovering around 9.8L/100km until I opened up the throttle a little bit a few times for some added fun as the weekend was unwinding.

Despite the Maxima’s questionable existence in Nissan’s lineup, they are selling and it is a well rounded car that is fun to drive and great on fuel with tons of passenger volume — you can’t go wrong here.

*Rating out of 5:

2009 Nissan Maxima 3.5 SV
Acceleration 4
Handling 4
Comfort 4half
Interior 4
Audio System 4
Gas Mileage 4half

*Rating based on vehicle’s classification

2009 Nissan Maxima 3.5 SV
MSRP as tested (including destination): $43,410

For more information on Nissan and the Maxima visit Nissan Canada

44 Responses to “Day-by-Day Review: 2009 Nissan Maxima 3.5 SV”


NOTE: This page displays the most recent 25 responses only.
to view the remaining posts please follow through to the forum thread.
  1. Jimmy Skum Says:
    Just spent 10 days driving one as a rental in AZ. An old man's car. Whiny in acceleration and not that quick, wallows in corners and just plain boring inside. Smooth and quiet at speed, 80 mph on the freeway, but more reminiscent of a Caddy than anything else. Had a sticker on the rear quarter light, 4DSC (four door sports car)! They must think they have to tell us or we won't know.

    The HP is close to my 335i but there is no comparison in handling, performance or quality. There is a price difference sure but worth every penny of that difference IMHO.
  2. wing Says:
    Wow, I guess I'm the only one that thinks this thing handles really well.  Certainly it doesn't wallow. 

    I think some people need to sit in the passenger seat with me for a few days, they will realize, almost all cars these days are more capable than 99% of drivers.
  3. Spheric Says:
    I miss the Racoon tail lights of the previous gen Maxima....  Grin
  4. Mitlov Says:
    Wow, I guess I'm the only one that thinks this thing handles really well.  Certainly it doesn't wallow. 

    I think some people need to sit in the passenger seat with me for a few days, they will realize, almost all cars these days are more capable than 99% of drivers.

    For the record, my beef with the Maxima isn't that it wallows (I've never driven it), but that it doesn't seem to fit a role distinct from the Altima and the G37.

    But I think your comment may miss the point that some people have made.  You don't need to reach a car's handling limits to dislike the way it "feels" as it goes down the road.  Am I a talented enough driver to push a Crown Victoria to its limits?  No.  Not at all.  But that doesn't mean I'll like how it "feels" compared to a 3-Series as I drive each awkwardly at a 7/10ths pace.
  5. wing Says:
    The new does feel sporty though, I'll get to that in Day 3.  The old one, not so much, but I guess a car is what you make of it.
  6. toolatecrew Says:
    Take an Accord, load her up to try and match the Maxima in equipment(and you can't) and you will pay $42000 for 1/3 the fun in driving and no comparison in looks.

    March sales in this category

    TSX (since Honda does not have a flagship car) 107
    Azera 27  Hurl
    Amanti 9  Hurl
    Avalon 39 Hurl
    Maxima 127  Grin
    Do you have figures for Genisis and G37 since both are comparably priced?

    I don't read to much into figuresd on a new Model introduction on the first couple of months. Its new after all.

    Please don't think that I am against the Maxima. I actually prefer the looks to the G37. My 99 Maxima is still going strong. I think the new Maxima is a step back in the right direction after the last few years.

    G35/37 310 vs Genesis 228

    April Numbers

    Maxima
    Genisis 370 Base Price 37,900
    G35 324 Base Price 37,900
    Maxima 133 Base Price 38,900

    Like I said I like the Maxima but one has to question Nissan thinking with where they position it. 

  7. Spec5 Says:
    Jimmy: I'm curious about your "quality" statement with regard to your 335i since the german manufacturers (BMW, Mercedes, Audi and VW) are all worse overall compared to Nissan.

    BMW (20), Mercedes(27), Audi (22) and VW (25)

    Nissan (14)

    Shockers: Hyundai (Cool, Kia (10), Mitsubishi (9), Scion (1)
  8. Factger Says:
    Sorry but I hate to say this but canadian sales's # do not express the success of the car as a whole.  Even on nissan's website they praise the sales of the 2009 maxima in "North America". It may not be as successfull in Canada right now but it is giving nissan something to smile about in these hard economic times.

    Quote
    NISSAN HIGHLIGHTS

    Nissan vehicles saw sales of 42,258 units in April compared with 66,318 units sold in April 2008, a decrease of 36.3 percent.
    April sales of the Nissan Z sports car totaled 1,561 units in April, a 29.2 percent increase from a year ago.
    Maxima sales of 3,901 in April were 62.7 percent higher than April 2008 sales of 2,398 cars.

    I have to say the base price seems to suck for canadians for sure compared to the other models. It must be the american dollar since it is manufactured in the US. I also think you have to look at the options each model has also. But I think the Genesis would have the best base options of the 3.

     


  9. ovr50 Says:
    Jimmy: I'm curious about your "quality" statement with regard to your 335i since the german manufacturers (BMW, Mercedes, Audi and VW) are all worse overall compared to Nissan.

    BMW (20), Mercedes(27), Audi (22) and VW (25)

    Nissan (14)

    Shockers: Hyundai (Cool, Kia (10), Mitsubishi (9), Scion (1)

    You are confusing "quality" with "reliability". The 335i has higher quality (as Jimmy said) but it may have worst reliability. Two different things.
  10. Jaeger Says:
    Wow, I guess I'm the only one that thinks this thing handles really well.  Certainly it doesn't wallow. 

    I think some people need to sit in the passenger seat with me for a few days, they will realize, almost all cars these days are more capable than 99% of drivers.

    No, you're not alone.  I have driven it and found it very well buttoned down.  Didn't even come close to "wallowing".

    Jaeger
  11. toolatecrew Says:
    Sorry but I hate to say this but canadian sales's # do not express the success of the car as a whole.  Even on nissan's website they praise the sales of the 2009 maxima in "North America". It may not be as successfull in Canada right now but it is giving nissan something to smile about in these hard economic times.

    Quote
    NISSAN HIGHLIGHTS

    Nissan vehicles saw sales of 42,258 units in April compared with 66,318 units sold in April 2008, a decrease of 36.3 percent.
    April sales of the Nissan Z sports car totaled 1,561 units in April, a 29.2 percent increase from a year ago.
    Maxima sales of 3,901 in April were 62.7 percent higher than April 2008 sales of 2,398 cars.

    I have to say the base price seems to suck for canadians for sure compared to the other models. It must be the american dollar since it is manufactured in the US. I also think you have to look at the options each model has also. But I think the Genesis would have the best base options of the 3.

     




    In the US the base Maxima is more "base" you can get one that doesn't have leather ,Bose audio of Fog lights for 30.190 US  35 K Can.

    The Base Canada Model is equivialant to the US SV Model.
    The Sv is 32,800 us or 38,400 equivialant in Canada (only $400 difference BRAVO Nissan on that one)

    If they offerd the base Maxima they would UNDERCUT the G5 and Genisis by 2K instead of being 1k more as entry level.

    Not sure the thinking on that.
  12. Jimmy Skum Says:
    I was providing my perception from 10 days of driving which finished last Sunday (10th), so very recent experience. I did many freeway miles and many in the city too at varied speeds. I am also an ex Maxima owner, two cars ago actually, last one was a G35 and now the 335i. I would take my old Maxima over the one I just drove, I think mine was a 2001.

    As I said my overall impression was that it reminded me of an American car, "soft" compared to the 2001 is how I would put it.

    Maybe I've been lucky with the 335i but I've had no issues with it and it's still real tight after two years.
  13. wing Says:
    I think your perception is off since you are use to a 335i now, a very tight and firm suspension.
  14. IceAndFire Says:
    I know the pricing isn't quite the same but would people compare this with say...a VW Passat CC?  I sort of see those two as being in the same area of car.  A relatively large sedan, with sporting intentions, a turn towards the "coupe" styling and sleek lines, and based on the more general mid-sized entry for that company.  Does everyone thats having a problem with the positioning for the Maxima also having the same perception of a positioning issue with the Passat CC?  Just curious.

    If I were older...and had the money.  I think it'd be between these two.  Course things could change when I actually get to be the age that I think these are oriented to.
  15. Factger Says:
    I was providing my perception from 10 days of driving which finished last Sunday (10th), so very recent experience. I did many freeway miles and many in the city too at varied speeds. I am also an ex Maxima owner, two cars ago actually, last one was a G35 and now the 335i. I would take my old Maxima over the one I just drove, I think mine was a 2001.

    As I said my overall impression was that it reminded me of an American car, "soft" compared to the 2001 is how I would put it.

    Maybe I've been lucky with the 335i but I've had no issues with it and it's still real tight after two years.

    I think it was the weight of the car was the reason your 2001 (3180lbs) might of felt more tighter compare to the 09 max (3560lbs). my 96 5 speed was under 3000lbs handled ok but was easy to toss around because it was so light. I am sure this 09 handles better than either car, it is just heavier.
  16. Mitlov Says:
    I know the pricing isn't quite the same but would people compare this with say...a VW Passat CC?  I sort of see those two as being in the same area of car.  A relatively large sedan, with sporting intentions, a turn towards the "coupe" styling and sleek lines, and based on the more general mid-sized entry for that company.  Does everyone thats having a problem with the positioning for the Maxima also having the same perception of a positioning issue with the Passat CC?  Just curious.

    If I were older...and had the money.  I think it'd be between these two.  Course things could change when I actually get to be the age that I think these are oriented to.

    Automobile Magazine recently did a comparison between a CC 2.0T, a Maxima, and a loaded Mazda6 V6.  I thought it was a fair comparison.

    And the VeeDub won  Grin
  17. banfield Says:
    "...they do not swoon me...".  Sorry mate, but "swoon" is not a transitive verb, so this reads very oddly. Of course, you can always argue creative license! 
  18. sailor723 Says:
    I know the pricing isn't quite the same but would people compare this with say...a VW Passat CC?  I sort of see those two as being in the same area of car.  A relatively large sedan, with sporting intentions, a turn towards the "coupe" styling and sleek lines, and based on the more general mid-sized entry for that company.  Does everyone thats having a problem with the positioning for the Maxima also having the same perception of a positioning issue with the Passat CC?  Just curious.

    If I were older...and had the money.  I think it'd be between these two.  Course things could change when I actually get to be the age that I think these are oriented to.

    Automobile Magazine recently did a comparison between a CC 2.0T, a Maxima, and a loaded Mazda6 V6.  I thought it was a fair comparison.

    And the VeeDub won  Grin

    Interesting comments....We're starting to look around for a replacement for our '05 Max (lease is up in Sept) and the CC is certainly among the possibles at the moment.
  19. Spec5 Says:
    Is the tip in on the throttle on this Maxima really touchy!? I find with my Sentra its VERY sensitive and its difficult to leave from a stop smoothly.
  20. wing Says:
    Most definitely now -- that is typically done on lower horsepower cars to make them feel fast.
  21. ovr50 Says:
    While I don't see a new Maxima (nor a Camry, nor an Accord) in my future, I do agree with James' comments.

    Back in 1992, when we bought a '92 Maxima SE, we did that after comparing to the Camry and the Accord. The Max, at that time, just felt more responsive, more powerful, and seemed to be the better handler of the three. The Camry was particularly boring on all counts, the Accord only slightly less so. We had the Max until '96, and my wife still says it was one of her favorite cars. And I didn't mind it either... Wink Wink

    Of the three again today, I would likely chose the Max.
  22. Factger Says:
    So after driving the maxima is the quote still valid. (in your genesis review)

    "If I were in the market for a vehicle such as a fully loaded Honda Accord or perhaps a Nissan Altima or Maxima, I would just skip them, walk into the Hyundai dealership and plunk down the coin for a Genesis."

     How does the maxima compare to the Genesis and G37 (my other prospective choices) in your opinion?

  23. wing Says:
    Genesis still wins for luxury for the $$$ -- it is a BARGAIN

    The Maxima is more sporty though.

    The G37 is not the same car as a Maxima, it drives TOTALLY differently and feels different, lucky me I just dropped the Maxima off and picked up the G37 again.  The G37 feels slightly stiffer.  The auto transmission reacts quite differently than the Maxima's and holds revs and drives more sporting.

    The Maxima is much larger though if you need the space. 

    All three cars are excellent, you would have to drive all three to decide.
  24. Jaeger Says:
    Genesis still wins for luxury for the $$$ -- it is a BARGAIN

    The Maxima is more sporty though.

    The G37 is not the same car as a Maxima, it drives TOTALLY differently and feels different, lucky me I just dropped the Maxima off and picked up the G37 again.  The G37 feels slightly stiffer.  The auto transmission reacts quite differently than the Maxima's and holds revs and drives more sporting.

    The Maxima is much larger though if you need the space. 

    All three cars are excellent, you would have to drive all three to decide.

    This is the kind of commentary I would love to see in a review - comparing the vehicles's attributes to both obvious and not-so-obvious competitors.

    Jaeger

  25. Factger Says:
    Genesis still wins for luxury for the $$$ -- it is a BARGAIN

    The Maxima is more sporty though.

    The G37 is not the same car as a Maxima, it drives TOTALLY differently and feels different, lucky me I just dropped the Maxima off and picked up the G37 again.  The G37 feels slightly stiffer.  The auto transmission reacts quite differently than the Maxima's and holds revs and drives more sporting.

    The Maxima is much larger though if you need the space. 

    All three cars are excellent, you would have to drive all three to decide.

    Yes I quess it comes down to the test drive and drivers preference. I prefer a sporty ride compared to a luxury ride. I have others factors such as kids and a wife that does not drive a manual and is used to front wheel drive. So it has to be front wheel drive or all wheel drive and have an automatic tranny. Does not look too good for the genesis but it is still an option since it it such a bargain. Ford Taurus SHO is another option that I am waiting results on.

    I hate to say it if the new max came with a 6 speed with the 370z downshift technology all reasoning would go out the window and I would buy it in a heartbeat. Even if I had to teach the wife to drive it. Lips Sealed

NOTE: This page displays the most recent 25 responses only.
to view the remaining posts please follow through to the forum thread.

Comments are closed.

© 2005 - 2008 CarTalkCanada & 1999 - 2008 CanadianDriver Communications Inc, all rights reserved.

You are visitor # to our site.

Click here to advertise
CarTalkCanada is a member
of the AOL Canada Media Network.
hit tracker