Home
CarTalk Blogs
General
Sedans
Coupes
Sports Cars
Trucks/SUVs
Forums
The Parking Lot
The Gravel Trail
The Showroom
The Garage
The Press Room
User Agreement
Contact Us
Should Drivers get re-tested for licensing?
Every 5 years
Every 10 years
After a certain age
Never


Total votes: 1658
View results

Blog Search
Archives

Don't miss these great features

Photo Galleries
1000s of photos, with full screen enlargements, all 2006 - 2009 models



More Day-by-Day Reviews


August 16th, 2007 by James Bergeron

Picture Gallery: 2008 Toyota Highlander     | Day 1 | Day 2 | Day 3| Day 4

Day 1:

2008 Toyota Highlander
Click Image to Enlarge
Perhaps you have seen the commercials recently on TV: a man parallel parks his SUV everyday at home and has hit the same tree and neighbour’s car countless times. In comes the new SUV — a 2008 Toyota Highlander — and he no longer hits the tree or car because of the reverse sensors.

A funny advertisement to say the least, but the base model Highlander doesn’t come with reverse sensors — I guess I’ll have to back into the neighbour’s car when I leave in the morning. This week I test drive the new 2008 Toyota Highlander, a base model 4WD with V6 engine.

2008 Toyota Highlander
Click Image to Enlarge
It has been a few weeks since I have been in a large SUV, and I had forgotten how big and cumbersome they were to drive, especially in small parking lots. Thankfully, the Highlander has light steering and fairly good visibility all around for those tight spots.

It is kind of nice to have a base model of a vehicle to test for a change; it seems to be happening a little more often lately, which is great for my readers even if it means I might have to “slum it” for a week. The Highlander comes standard with Toyota’s amazing 270hp 3.5litre V6 engine mated to a five-speed automatic transmission and four-wheel drive.


Other notable standard drivetrain features include: hill descent control, snow mode, hill-hold brake assist, four-wheel ABS, stability control and electronic brake distribution — certainly nothing to sneeze at. On the inside, standard items include: cloth seats, air-conditioning, stereo equipped with AM/FM/CD/MP3/WMA capability, auxiliary input and six speakers and a whackload of cup-holders.

The new Highlander looks sharp and initial driving impressions are pretty good. I have high hopes for its fuel efficiency knowing Toyota’s record and this engine, but this is not a small vehicle — we’ll see how it goes.

2008 Toyota Highlander
MSRP as tested: $41,340

For more information on Toyota and the Highlander visit Toyota Canada

Day 2:

2008 Toyota Highlander
Click Image to Enlarge
The size of the Higlander has me a little confused. From the outside the Highlander looks rather large. From the driving position it feels rather large, even though the light steering allows you to steer easily and helps to make the vehicle feel slightly smaller.

Behind the front row is where everything seems to change. I expected a much larger second row and with the middle seat of the second row being pretty much useless, the Highlander — touted as a seven seater — turns into a vehicle that really can only hold four comfortably.

2008 Toyota Highlander
Click Image to Enlarge
The third row seats may be useful for small children, but I would certainly not want to be back there for any length of time. So here we have a rather large SUV that can only seat four people. If cargo capacity is your requirement, the Highlander has it, with a boxy design even with just the third row of seats folded down; a good amount of cargo space is available for your shopping pleasure.

My first thought when entering the Highlander was that the dash looked like the electronics aisle at Future Shop. I especially like the large dials used for the stereo controls, a very modern electronic look that is used on large stereo systems.

The HVAC system carries on the theme with very easy to read and use dials. Actually, all the buttons and dials on the Highlander are adorned with huge text that is very easy to read at a glance or if your eyesight is failing. This is a similar design to the new Camry as well, and although some may dislike it, I am glad for it in a world of more and more buttons that are hard to read, especially when you should be keeping your eyes on the road ahead.

Day 3:

2008 Toyota Highlander
Click Image to Enlarge
Even though I came down pretty hard on the Highlander yesterday for the seating arrangements, I will come back today with some praise. The Highlander’s driving dynamics are extremely capable and pleasing for a vehicle of this size and weight.

My test model weights in at 4,178lbs, which is pretty standard for a vehicle of this size, though some of the driving dynamics it possesses do not seem to jive with that. First is the handling: although not sports-car-like, the Highlander does handle fairly well and does not feel as though it is about to flip over when tossed around a corner. The steering is pretty vague and light feeling; off-road this could be an issue when trying to negotiate a rock.

2008 Toyota Highlander
Click Image to Enlarge
The brakes are somewhat puzzling — these do feel like brakes from a sports car. Touch them gently and you come to a crisp stop, touch them slightly more than gently and you eat the steering wheel for breakfast on your way to work. They are a wee bit on the touchy side, although easy enough to get used to and while I’m certain they aid in panic stop situations, they could make your passenger queasy if you reach for them too often.

Another place where Toyota delivers is the engine. In the Highlander,this is the same one used in the Camry V6 and the Rav4; one would think hauling this much extra weight around, performance would suffer, but it does not. The Highlander scuttles along smoothly and easily, so that keeping up with or ahead of traffic takes very little throttle response — as a result is a real joy to drive around town.

So there you have it, Toyota has a reputation for making boring appliance-like vehicles, but they provide their large SUV with the dynamics of a sports car — okay, perhaps that is stretching it a little too far, but for a vehicle in this segment it is somewhat engaging with good power, good brakes and great acceleration.

Day 4:

2008 Toyota Highlander
Click Image to Enlarge
The more I drove the Highlander during the course of the week and the more I thought about the content provided in the $41,000 base model Highlander, the more I came to the realization that this vehicle does not equate to a very good dollar-to-content ratio.

I cannot say the Highlander does not provide value, as value can mean many things to many people, but as far as content and features for the dollar the Highlander is lacking. There is nothing in the Highlander that really stands out as exceptional — perhaps a case could be made for the engine.

I wasn’t able to get very many kilometers on the Highlander this week, but averaged around 11.5L/100km, in mostly city driving, which is excellent for a vehicle of this size and better than Transport Canada’s estimated city mileage of 12.3L/100km. I will try to report back with an update after a little more driving this coming weekend, but as expected, Toyota did a great job on fuel economy.

With the abundance of crossovers/ SUVs and other utility vehicles heading to the market I do not see a compelling reason to jump at the Highlander. The RAV4 provides nearly the same amount of room with more style and the same engine. If you really need the seven seats, you may want to look for something that will provide your passengers with more comfort. Perhaps you won’t be as “cool” but the Sienna would do the job.

*Rating out of 5:

2008 Toyota Highlander
Acceleration 4"
Handling 3half
Comfort 3
Interior 3
Audio System 3
Gas Mileage 3

*Rating based on vehicle’s classification

2008 Toyota Highlander
MSRP as tested: $41,340

For more information on Toyota and the Highlander visit Toyota Canada

67 Responses to “Day-by-Day Review: 2008 Toyota Highlander”


NOTE: This page displays the most recent 25 responses only.
to view the remaining posts please follow through to the forum thread.
  1. MKII Says:
    The  execution  of the audio-HVAC  face plate http://www.canadiandriver.com/ctc_gallery/images/toyota/2008_toyota_highlander/highlander_jb_16-1997.jpg  IMO looks like some of the robot faces that I see on  the animated cartoon shows my daughter watches.  Maybe user friendly, but very ugly IMO.
  2. airbalancer Says:
    The  execution  of the audio-HVAC  face plate http://www.canadiandriver.com/ctc_gallery/images/toyota/2008_toyota_highlander/highlander_jb_16-1997.jpg  IMO looks like some of the robot faces that I see on  the animated cartoon shows my daughter watches.  Maybe user friendly, but very ugly IMO.
    Where is the aux plug in?
    Does the upper level have duel zone climate controls?
  3. ovr50 Says:
    Neighbour about 6 houses down the street just traded in his '01 HL for a new '08 HL Limited in a new color, a light blue metallic with grey leather interior. Has 19" alloys as part of the Limited pkg. I only had a brief look at it but looks a lot better in real life than the pictures.

    I think those that say the new HL won't sell well are not right, my guess it will sell nearly as well as the old one. But who knows?
  4. initial_D Says:
    The  execution  of the audio-HVAC  face plate http://www.canadiandriver.com/ctc_gallery/images/toyota/2008_toyota_highlander/highlander_jb_16-1997.jpg  IMO looks like some of the robot faces that I see on  the animated cartoon shows my daughter watches.  Maybe user friendly, but very ugly IMO.
    Where is the aux plug in?
    Does the upper level have duel zone climate controls?

    The AUX audio input jack would be located on the center console somewhere, a better location than in the dash.

    I don't think there is dual zone climate control, only one set of temperature and fan speed knobs.
  5. Jack B Says:
    Great interior, but the styling is generic Toyugly
  6. sirAQUAMAN64 Says:
    I think those that say the new HL won't sell well are not right, my guess it will sell nearly as well as the old one. But who knows?

    Local Toyota dealer here has nearly 20 of them on the lot, so they must be expecting brisk sales from someplace.
  7. si Says:
    So... the American Highlander starts at $27,300 USD, with the limited going to $32,700 (a difference of $5,400)

    The Canadian Highlander starts at $39,650 CAD (more than buying a limited one from the US), reaching to $50,ish - more than a 10 grand difference.

    Toyota USA > Toyota Canada
  8. mdxtasy Says:
    So... the American Highlander starts at $27,300 USD, with the limited going to $32,700 (a difference of $5,400)

    The Canadian Highlander starts at $39,650 CAD (more than buying a limited one from the US), reaching to $50,ish - more than a 10 grand difference.

    Toyota USA > Toyota Canada

    http://www.canadiandriver.com/forum/index.php/topic,53505.0.html
  9. sailor723 Says:
    Either the resellers/brokers will be getting in on the action or hungry US dealers will be sending in RDR's in the names of their cousin's,friends,neighbours and then changing the ownership info after a month or two.
  10. 2hondas Says:
    I saw many on a lot at a Toyota dealership in Sault St. Marie, this past weekend.
  11. jcon Says:
    I saw many on a lot at a Toyota dealership in Sault St. Marie, this past weekend.
    I wonder if Toyota dealerships pre-ordered a bunch anticipating a rush on sales when they were launched? Maybe they read the market wrong?
  12. 2hondas Says:
    I saw many on a lot at a Toyota dealership in Sault St. Marie, this past weekend.
    I wonder if Toyota dealerships pre-ordered a bunch anticipating a rush on sales when they were launched? Maybe they read the market wrong?


    I am not sure...maybe. But I saw one 08' dark greenish one when driving south of Sudbury, yesterday afternoon. First one I saw on the road.
  13. ovr50 Says:
    I saw many on a lot at a Toyota dealership in Sault St. Marie, this past weekend.
    I wonder if Toyota dealerships pre-ordered a bunch anticipating a rush on sales when they were launched? Maybe they read the market wrong?

    The vehicle is just barely available in dealer's hands, and you are surmissing that because they have some on the lots just received, it is not selling well? Pretty big assumption to make so early in the game... Roll Eyes Roll Eyes
  14. jcon Says:
    The vehicle is just barely available in dealer's hands, and you are surmissing that because they have some on the lots just received, it is not selling well? Pretty big assumption to make so early in the game... Roll Eyes Roll Eyes

    I'm not surmising anything, I'm wondering. I'm also not suggesting this vehicle won't be a hit. Previous Highlanders have sold well and I have no reason to believe this one won't as well.

    I'm WONDERING whether the dealers have taken a lot of pre-orders and that these Highlanders are waiting to be picked up or whether dealers are loading up on them while they can or maybe Toyota has been building them for quite some time and have a huge inventory or whatever...

    Sometimes one can wonder without drawing conclusions.
  15. Raf Says:
    The vehicle is just barely available in dealer's hands, and you are surmissing that because they have some on the lots just received, it is not selling well? Pretty big assumption to make so early in the game... Roll Eyes Roll Eyes

    I'm not surmising anything, I'm wondering. I'm also not suggesting this vehicle won't be a hit. Previous Highlanders have sold well and I have no reason to believe this one won't as well.

    I'm WONDERING whether the dealers have taken a lot of pre-orders and that these Highlanders are waiting to be picked up or whether dealers are loading up on them while they can or maybe Toyota has been building them for quite some time and have a huge inventory or whatever...

    Sometimes one can wonder without drawing conclusions.

    I think most dealership will put the newly redesigned car in their dealership for a month or so (same case happen with tundra).. Because mostly their new car compound is full as this moment and waiting for the old stock(07 models) to go out .Eventually, the dealership  slowly ship those HL  back to their compound.  It is just for advertising as well as ran out of room at their inventory compound.
  16. hondacura Says:
    On the Toyota website, "automatic door closer" is listed as standard equipment on the SR5 and Limited.  What exactly is that, and I wonder why it is not available on the Sport?
  17. airbalancer Says:
    saw a pearl white one as I drove by the dealer, looks very nice

    airbalancer, you've been checking out vehicles in this category, I would like to know your assessment of this one as well.

    Finially went to see one, and it was very nice, driving position was excellant( did not go for a drive), room behind the seat was also good, base model did not look to bad.
    But to spend $51gs on a load model , I dont know if I could.
    By the way who could fit in a RAVA 4, it just felt wrong in the drivers seat
  18. Benhaze Says:
    saw a pearl white one as I drove by the dealer, looks very nice

    airbalancer, you've been checking out vehicles in this category, I would like to know your assessment of this one as well.

    Finially went to see one, and it was very nice, driving position was excellant( did not go for a drive), room behind the seat was also good, base model did not look to bad.
    But to spend $51gs on a load model , I dont know if I could.
    By the way who could fit in a RAVA 4, it just felt wrong in the drivers seat

    Holy cow airbalancer, were you partying early on October 17th?   Grin
  19. AVToller Says:
    By the way, "who" is correct (it is NOT "whom"), although it should have been preceded by a comma and the rest of the sentence is just plain wrong.  Wink
  20. Benhaze Says:
    By the way, "who" is correct (it is NOT "whom"), although it should have been preceded by a comma and the rest of the sentence is just plain wrong.  Wink

    That's what I meant... The sentence would have been a little better if the words "for me who"... would have been used instead of just "who".

    airbalancer, do you feel you're back on a school bench yet?  Wink
  21. Visitor294 Says:
    I have visited your site 446-times
  22. ovr50 Says:
    I have visited your site 446-times

    Wow, why not sign on and become a regular contributor then?? You would be welcome.  Smiley
  23. sirAQUAMAN64 Says:
    saw a pearl white one as I drove by the dealer, looks very nice

    airbalancer, you've been checking out vehicles in this category, I would like to know your assessment of this one as well.

    Finially went to see one, and it was very nice, driving position was excellant( did not go for a drive), room behind the seat was also good, base model did not look to bad.
    But to spend $51gs on a load model , I dont know if I could.
    By the way who could fit in a RAVA 4, it just felt wrong in the drivers seat

    I found the Highlander quite comfortable as well. Rear headroom in 2nd row kind of tight (had a sunroof) but the front was a good place to be. Controls are solid too.

    The RAV not really at all.
  24. sirAQUAMAN64 Says:
    Consumer Reports ranks 2008 Highlander No. 1
    But 'recommended' tag is withheld under new policy

    Ryan Beene
    Automotive News
    December 5, 2007 - 4:49 pm ET   
     
    DETROIT -- The redesigned 2008 Toyota Highlander scores No. 1 on the Consumer Reports list of top mid-size, three-row SUVs, but it doesn't get an automatic “Recommended” designation by the magazine in its latest issue.

    The Highlander is the first vehicle to be hit by the magazine’s Oct. 16 decision to not automatically award the “Recommended” designation to Toyota vehicles.

    The 2008 Highlander scored better than 13 competing mid-size, three-row SUVs to take the segment’s top spot in the magazine’s January ratings, but it was not officially recommended because “we recommend only models with sufficient data to predict average or better reliability,” David Champion, senior director of Consumer Reports Auto Test Center, said in a statement.

    The Highlander received high marks for its ride comfort, quiet interior, refinement, power, fuel economy and second-row seat. It was criticized for a light steering feel, a lack of versatility in the third-row seat and for not being very agile.

    In the past, Consumer Reports said it automatically gave the “Recommended” moniker to new and redesigned Toyotas based on the company’s excellent reliability history. If reliability of Toyota vehicles returns to “excellent” levels for a sustained period, Consumer Reports said it will resume automatic recommendations, according to a press release.The redesigned Highlander, nonetheless, finished at the top the list with a rating of 81.

    Other vehicles tested in the January issue were the Buick Enclave, Ford Taurus X and Subaru Tribeca, whose ratings along with the Highlander were added to the magazine’s existing rankings of 10 other midsize, three-row SUVs.

    The Tribeca and Taurus X got the “Recommended” nod, even though scores came in at 70 for the Tribeca and 75 for the Taurus X. The Buick Enclave also scored 75 in the latest round of testing.

    Below the top-ranked Highlander, the Enclave placed sixth, the Taurus X took seventh and the Tribeca came in eleventh in the updated tests.

    Other existing top ratings included the Acura MDX at No. 2 with a score of 80. The Honda Pilot was No. 3 with a 79 rating.
  25. safristi Says:
    Party On DUDE.......I bet ya don't give a HVAC'K

NOTE: This page displays the most recent 25 responses only.
to view the remaining posts please follow through to the forum thread.

Comments are closed.

© 2005 - 2008 CarTalkCanada & 1999 - 2008 CanadianDriver Communications Inc, all rights reserved.

You are visitor # to our site.

Click here to advertise
CarTalkCanada is a member
of the AOL Canada Media Network.
hit tracker